Fluffernutter, if you’ve never heard, is originally a sandwich said to have originated in New England, Massachusetts that combines two calorie-laden ingredients between two layers of bread. Those ingredients of course are marshmallow “fluff” and peanut butter. It’s hard to say no to something that sounds THAT delicious. Over the years, recipe creators and home bakers have paid homage to the sandwich with other fluffernuttery combinations. So here is a list to get you started on what’s sure to be your latest obsession, but one that just looks more put together than you just grabbing a spoonful of peanut butter and then a spoonful of marshmallow fluff and calling it a day. Although, that does sound equally amazing.

1. Fluffernutter Cookies

This may look as simple as peanut butter cookies with a marshmallow fluff center layer, but oh it’s so much more. That fluff filling is a marshmallow fluff frosting that will take these cookies to new heights. Not quite a whoopie pie, not quite a fluffernutter sandwich, but one perfect mashup none the less .

2. Fluffernutter Puppy Chow

Puppy chow is that sweet and salty, crunchy and delicious snack that makes the perfect party food for little fingers. Give that idea a fluffernutter twist, and you’ll have these little pups, that will keep you going back for more.

3. Fluffernutter Blondies

Sweet goodness gracious. This is one of those desserts that could be considered a bad idea, purely because you’re bound to lick the batter, lick the pan, and lick all the blondies, so that no one else can have any.

4. Fluffernutter Milkshake

Who has time for baking, anyway? Let’s just throw it all in a blender (which, by the way, is only 5 ingredients) and call it a day; a delicious fluffernutter milkshake day.

5. Fluffernutter Squares

Only THREE ingredients! This is so simple, kids can easily help you create these, then push them aside while you eat them all. Kidding! Sharing is caring. If you’re into that sort of thing.

Advertisement

6. Fluffernutter Quesadillas

Because why freaking NOT? Also, because it’s incredibly simple…and again, only three ingredients. This recipe serves two, or an ambitious one.

7. Fluffernutter French Toast Casserole

Classic french toast casserole, with bananas, chocolate chips and of course, that fluffernutter twist. Great for baking an indulgent breakfast for a crowd, with an easy prep and let your oven do the rest.

8. Elvis Fluffernutter Cupcakes

Uh, Elvis? Yeah, Elvis! Famously known for his love of a peanut butter, banana (and bacon) sandwich, this cupcake celebrates that crazy delicious combination and one-ups it with a marshmallow frosting!

9. Fluffernutter Monkey Bread

Monkey bread is that easy to make, pull-apart bundt cake that is all that’s right the world. It’s even better when you mix in peanut butter and marshmallow flavors, and then drizzle more on top for good measure.

Advertisement

10. Fluffernutter Waffles

Waffles layered with crunchy peanut butter, marshmallow fluff and topped with crunchy peanuts? #breakfastgoals

11. Butterscotch Fluffernutter Krispy Bars

With only seven ingredients and 30 minutes of prep, you can have these ooey gooeys taking up real estate in your mouth, and if you’re nice – some of your loved one’s mouths, too.

Sarah Nicole

Since successfully losing 100lbs by changing her relationship with food and her body, Sarah has taken her passion for food and balanced it between cucumbers and cupcakes. When she's not bustling her way around a kitchen, you can find her working out or winding down at home with her 3 kids and pug. Follow Sarah's journey on Instagram @TheBirdsPapaya.

Energy balls are a great way to stay healthy and obviously - energized, while on the go!
Mmmm, chocolate chip cookies are one of those comforts from home I can never say no to.
At the end of a long, warm day swimming in the sunshine, meeting up with friends and sipping on some ice cold drinks, the best way...
Ice cream cakes are absolutely to DIE for. Have you heard of ice cream pies though?
Peach season is the best season! It's such a sweet and juicy fruit that is perfect for a day at the beach or in the place of a...
What's better than a pie? A turnover! Why? Because a pie is made for a group of people, while turnovers are made especially for...
When I was a kid, fudge was something that so rich and decadent it came around maybe once a year.
When we crave chocolate, rarely do our minds first go to white chocolate. Why is that?
When you think of a warm day, what flavors come to mind? Maybe some BBQ flavors like hamburgers, hot dogs and grilled veggies.
Have you offered to bring a dessert to a dinner party or family gathering before and then realized a few hours before the get...
So another year has passed and your little trick or treaters have come home with a sack full of candy, and right at the bottom is...
There's something incredibly heartwarming when baking cookies, especially when they are easy to make, and come out perfectly.
Advertisement
Recipes
Magical Rainbow Unicorn Squares