Summer is finally here and it’s a hot one! The easiest way to cool down (besides living in front of the A/C unit) is a cold treat, straight from the freezer! And boy do we have a good one for you! These pudding popsicles are reminiscent of the ones Jell-O used to make, but you can make them at home with only a few ingredients, making them super inexpensive. Both you and your littles are sure to enjoy them, so what are you waiting for?!

Looking for another frosty summer treat? Check out our Easy 5-Ingredient Copycat Wendy’s Frosty!

Advertisement

Start by making the chocolate, butterscotch, and vanilla instant pudding packets according to the instructions on the packaging. We used Jell-O brand and each kind required two cups of cold milk. Allow it to thicken properly before moving onto the next step – this will make the final pop super creamy.

Add a full cup of Cool Whip to each type of pudding and whisk in well, ensuring the no lumps remain. The pudding should look more pastel after the addition of the Cool Whip, making for some very pretty popsicles.

Three boxes makes a lot of pudding, so if you won’t have a ton of popsicles molds, try halving this recipe and only making half of each package of Instant Jell-O Pudding. You can save the rest for the next time you want to make these!

Make sure your popsicle molds are washed and dried. Using a spoon, measuring cup, or piping bag, layer in the vanilla pudding, followed by the butterscotch and chocolate puddings. Make sure that each type fills about 1/3 of each mold. Between each layer, tap the mold onto the table or countertop to even out layers and remove any air bubbles.

Advertisement

Don’t fill them too full! Otherwise, the pudding may overflow and create a bit of a mess. Stick the popsicle sticks into each of the molds and transfer to the freezer for at least 6 hours or until fully frozen.

When they’re fully frozen, they’re ready to be eaten! Gently twist the stick to release the popsicle from the mold and lift out. If you’re having trouble, run some hot water over the sides of the mold of the particular popsicle you’re trying to remove for about 5-10 seconds to help release the pudding pop! Enjoy quickly or it may melt!

Servings: 20-30

Ingredients

  • Box of instant chocolate Jell-O pudding
  • Box of instant vanilla Jello-O pudding
  • Box of instant butterscotch Jello-O pudding
  • 6 cups cold milk
  • 3 cups of Cool Whip

Equipment

  • Popsicle molds
  • Electric beaters or stand mixer

Method

  • In three separate bowls, mix each box of instant pudding with 2 cups of milk each. Whisk well according to package instructions.
  • Add 1 cup of whipped cream (or Cool Whip) into each bowl and whisk until well combined.
  • Allow pudding to sit for five minutes (to thicken).
  • Alternate layers of chocolate, butterscotch, and vanilla pudding in the popsicle molds. Push the stick lids into the molds and freeze for at least 6 hours or overnight.

Notes

If you prefer, replace the Cool Whip with 2 cups of whipping cream, 2 tsp vanilla, and 3 tbsp sugar to make homemade whipped cream.

Switch up or add other pudding flavors to your liking!

Our popsicle molds were quite narrow so we found using a piping bag very helpful to be able to neatly add the layers of pudding.

Between each layer, tap the mold onto the table or countertop to even out layers and reduce air bubbles.

The servings may vary depending on the size and shape of your popsicle molds.

Rhiannon Ball

Rhiannon loves to cook and bake but has also never said "no" to a takeout burrito (see, she's just like you!). Despite slowly running out of room in her cabinets, she continues to expand her collections of cookbooks and kitchen gadgets and is deeply jealous of people who can just "whip something up" without a recipe. When she's not in the kitchen, you can find her camping and hiking with her husband and rescue dog, Waffles.

There are countless reasons why chicken is a go-to food for every meal.
Enjoy the fresh flavors of Mediterranean cooking that will have you dreaming of lounging next to the sea without having to fly...
Spring has sprung and Easter is right around the corner! Whether it's a cute treat for your kiddo's class, an office potluck, or...
It's officially Spring weather and we're ready to trade our heavy comfort foods for light and bright flavors (even if this recipe...
Cooking is half the battle when it comes to busy weeknights. Washing the dishes is the other dreadful task.
The last thing we want to do after a busy day is to spend hours in the kitchen prepping, cooking, and cleaning up dinner.
When the snack cravings hit we all know how easy it is to reach for the most accessible thing in sight.
Encouraging your kids to eat more than noodles and sauce can be difficult.
Dealing with picky eaters is never easy. It can be a never-ending battle trying to get them to eat dinner but we're here to put a...
Following a new diet can be both exciting and daunting and following through with that diet is never easy!
Barbeque sauce is a summer staple, but it's a hard one to get around if you're on the Keto diet since it's generally packed full...
Summer is one of the most anticipated seasons of the year! I mean, why wouldn't you love it?
Advertisement
Food
Easy Make Ahead Salads