Has anyone else been seeing versions of Big Mac Sauce popping up at the grocery store? I sure have. But I don’t love the long list of ingredients I can’t pronounce. And to be honest, I grew up exclusively with homemade burgers and so I actually don’t like McDonald’s burgers very much, so it’s not even as if I can just get my fix by going through the drive-thru! But I do love a good burger sauce, which is part of the reason why I wanted to make this absolutely delish copycat recipe. Let me tell you, it’s mind-blowing how much this tastes like the real deal. There is absolutely no mistaking it!

Whether you’re trying to recreate a Big Mac at home (with cleaner ingredients and on the cheap!) or you just want a tasty sauce to dress up your dinner that isn’t just ketchup, we’ve got you covered with this easy Copycat Big Mac Sauce.

Advertisement

It really is simple and I’d bet that you already have all (except one) the ingredients you need, so it’s incredibly inexpensive to make. That one ingredient? Dill pickle relish. You can get it at any grocery store, but most often it’s considered gourmet and comes in a glass jar instead of a squeeze bottle. To make the sauce, simply add everything to a bowl and mix well to combine. Make sure you whisk long enough to get rid of any lumps, with the exception of the relish.

This Big Mac Sauce is a great dip or burger topping for those on the Keto diet, as it’s low carb and high fat. It’s also incredibly easy to make vegan – simply sub out the regular mayonnaise for vegan mayo and slather on the veggie burger!

The sauce can be used in many ways. Spoon onto burgers, sliders, sausages, hot dogs; use as a dip for fries or kabobs, or even drizzle on pizza! It’s incredible how accurate this copycat recipe is, so go ahead and put it on whatever you want. We won’t judge!

Servings: 24

Ingredients

  • 1 cup mayonnaise
  • 1/3 cup dill pickle relish
  • 3 tbsp mustard
  • 1 1/2 tsp white wine vinegar
  • 1 tsp paprika
  • 1 tsp onion powder
  • 1 tsp garlic powder

Method

  • In a bowl, mix together all of the ingredients until well combined and no lumps remain (besides the relish).
  • Either cover the bowl and place in the fridge or transfer to a container or mason jar for storage.
  • Use on burger or whatever other food you desire!

Rhiannon Ball

Rhiannon loves to cook and bake but has also never said "no" to a takeout burrito (see, she's just like you!). Despite slowly running out of room in her cabinets, she continues to expand her collections of cookbooks and kitchen gadgets and is deeply jealous of people who can just "whip something up" without a recipe. When she's not in the kitchen, you can find her camping and hiking with her husband and rescue dog, Waffles.

Is anybody else obsessed with Heluva Good Dip? I'm seriously addicted.
What is your biggest challenge when you start a new diet? For me, it's sugar. Forget the deep fried food - I can skip that.
Many of us start our day with a trip to Starbucks and fuel our day with a cup of coffee.
Have you ever gone out for supper, eaten the best food you could think of and then crave it for weeks to come?
Let's face it, Starbucks is highly addictive. With their long lists of beverages and delicious meals and snack bar, they have...
Growing up fast food visits were some of the most exciting dinners my siblings and I looked forward to.
Buckle up, friends. This recipe is over the top, reach for a third one, I can't believe I made these at home delicious.
We love a good copycat recipe here at Forkly and this Wendy's chocolate frosty is no exception!
There is perhaps nothing quite as easy to whip up on a busy weeknight as Hamburger Helper.
Trader Joe's is known for several popular grocery staples. Among them is their famous Everything But the Bagel Sesame Seasoning...
Summer is the most anticipated season of the year! We can enjoy the outdoors, dig into delicious BBQ, and of course, indulge in...
Purchasing boxed/bagged food products from the grocery store is convenient, however, I truly believe nothing compares to the...
Advertisement
Recipes
Easy Instant Pot Keto BBQ Chicken Wings