There’s something…well…magical…yes, Christmas magical about a Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup. Trust me, I’ve put peanut butter on a spoon and sprinkled it with chocolate chips, it’s just not the same. It’s more than just chocolate and peanut butter. Arguably there’s some sort of addictive element added into it that keeps us coming back for more. Some of us, are just itching for an excuse to use them in holiday recipes.  Why? Well, taste testing of course, it’s the best part of holiday baking! Also, not to mention the praise and glory you get with a sure-fire win by adding that simple ingredient – Reese Cups. Here’s some recipes to keep you riding high among the cookie exchanges, dessert tables and bake sales. Rumor has it, it’s Santa’s favorite chocolate too. Batter up!

1. Reese’s Christmas Trees

Stack ’em up, and put a kiss on top! Just you try and resist eating the entire tree at once (challenge accepted?!)

2. Reese’s Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies

Peanut butter cookies are pretty incredible as-is. But WOW factor with these one with the surprise inside of a whole peanut butter cup?! This is how you win cookie competitions, friends.

3. Christmas Bark Cookie Crunch (with Reese’s too, but of course!)

Barks are a life saver during the holidays. No baking required, they are actually meant to be broken, and they have the ability to be stored away for weeks. Always a good idea to have some made on hand for when that neighbor brings you over a tin of cookies and you’re stuck looking like a jerk with nothing for them. Have a few baggies of these on hand, and you’ll always win friends with peanut butter cups. It’s like the law of friendship. Unless they’re allergic, then that’s probably the law of ruining friendships, real fast.

4. Reese’s Krispy Cookies

NO BAKE, again! Just saving your Christmas baking tushies right now. These rice krispy hybrid peanut butter cookies are like Christmas crack, of the peanut butter variety.

5. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Brownie Explosion

EXPLOSION! Of peanut butter cup, and brownie. Preheat the oven, lets go!

Advertisement

6. Rudolph The Red Nosed Reese Cup

Had a very edible nose…and body…and…mmm…

7. Reese Peanut Butter Cheesecake Dip

Gather ’round the cheesecake dip in holly jolly delight!

 

8. Peanut Butter Cup Muddy Buddies

Aka puppy chow (heads up – not for actual puppies!). Muddy buddies or puppy chow is the perfect no-bake snack to put out during the holidays. It looks snow dusted and has mini Reese peanut butter cups mixed through it!

9. Slow Cooker Reese’s Peanut Butter Swirl Cake

With all these holiday parties and potlucks, you know you’re bound to be in a parade of slow cookers and crock pots. Take a new spin on things by bringing along a dessert cake, in a slow cooker. Plus, nobody is going to pass up those peanut butter cups adorning the cake’s surface. Mmmm…

Advertisement

10. Reese’s Cake Roll

Cake rolls always remind me of the holidays. In my house, they are usually made during the holidays, and considered a “yule log” cake. Frankly, I’m just happy for more peanut butter recipes in my life, and a charming excuse to make this recipe.

Sarah Nicole

Since successfully losing 100lbs by changing her relationship with food and her body, Sarah has taken her passion for food and balanced it between cucumbers and cupcakes. When she's not bustling her way around a kitchen, you can find her working out or winding down at home with her 3 kids and pug. Follow Sarah's journey on Instagram @TheBirdsPapaya.

More Forkly
Christmas will be here before you know it, so it's time to pull out your decorations and start baking!
Eggnog can be a hot topic over the holidays. Some tend to think it's a disgusting concoction, while the rest of us are swooned by...
We've all been there. You need to bring a dessert to a Holiday function and you're lacking time, or general baking skills.
So either you or a someone at your holiday dinner is gluten-intolerant or celiac, and/or perhaps vegan or working towards a...
It's winding down, Christmas is nearly here. When it comes to the difficult to shop for, there's always a need for kitchen gadgets...
Chocolate barks are my absolute favorite go-to for large batch treats you can store for weeks and hand out as needed to neighbors,...
Between Thanksgiving, Christmas & New Years - it's Holiday season, full force.
With the holidays comes seasonal flavors that will capture the essence of the season, and create warm holiday memories.
They like pig butts and they cannot lie! Now you need to get shopping for your bacon enthusiast and try and be a little more...
I'm not sure how your family does the holiday feasts, but in our home - stuffing was king.
When it comes to making mashed potatoes, one word may enter your mind..."tedious".
The holidays are known to be the hardest season of the year in terms of the age-old battle of the bulge.
Advertisement
Food
Easy Christmas Party Dessert Recipes: 7 Great Ideas!