In the weeks leading up to my favorite holiday, Halloween, I like to add some spine-tingling fun to the appetizers, entrees, and even the desserts that I lay on my table.

Introducing the spookiest, scariest, and most sinister Halloween-worthy spread…

1. Little Devil Devilled Eggs

For a tray of “horror d’oeuvres” that will send chills down your spine, whip up a dozen of these sinful (aka: delicious as H-E-double hockey sticks) devilled eggs—made fiery red with spicy hot pepper sauce and paprika, and topped with cherry tomato horns and olive eyes and scowls.

Little-Devil-Deviled-Eggs-52919

Source: Kraft Recipes

2. Dead Man’s Finger Sandwiches

This recipe for dead man’s finger sandwiches takes Halloween quite literally! Set your lunch time mood to scream when you serve 5 creepy digits made with thin-sliced white bread, peanut butter, strawberry jam (or sticky blood) and almonds to tip each as nails. Don’t forget to serve with extra blood (strawberry jam).

DeadmansFinger_A_393227

Source: Parenting.com

3. Meatball Mummies

Adorable to behold and delectable to eat—these meatball mummies are 3 frozen or homemade meat balls (you can use beef, turkey, or chicken) wrapped snuggly in crisscrossed dough. The recipes calls for a piece of dried spaghetti to keep your meatballs straight and secure…because there’s nothing more frightening than a mummy falling out of his wraps. Dress with edible eyes or make your own eyeballs with a dab of mayo and ketchup.

Deliciously-adorable-Meatball-Mummies-Easy-to-make-fun-to-eat1

Source: Spend With Pennies

4. Spooky Potato Candy Spiders

Watch old-fashioned Halloween candies transform into creepy candy spiders, right before your very eyes! With a flavor and texture similar to Mounds bars, traditional potato candy is made with mashed potatoes, vanilla, coconut, and melted dark chocolate. Use pretzel sticks for spider’s legs and sugar sprinkles for sinister arachnid eyes.

Potato-Candy-Spiders-7

Source: That Skinny Chick Can Bake

5. Graveyard Cupcakes

This graveyard is alive with the flavors of…cupcakes! It might not seem very scary until you rest your terrified gaze on this tombstone, ghost, and ghoul-ridden graveyard, which uses individual cupcakes to form a flat cake base. The scariest part is that it’s eaten knife-free, encouraging little goblins to leave a carnage of marshmallows, frosting, cookie crumbs, lollypops, and licorice whips in their wake.

Graveyard-Cupcakes_s4x3.jpg.rend.snigalleryslide

Source: Food Network

Advertisement

6. Meat Hand

For a gruesome take on a classic comfort meal, try your hand at a cheese-infused meat loaf, made with ketchup (blood), a whole onion (wrist bone), and onion pieces (for nails). You’ll require a hand-shaped gelatin mold to shape your raw meat blend, then bake, and set on a tray surrounded by mashed potatoes and kale (brain matter), and ketchup (for more blood).

meat hand

Source: Not Martha

7. Monster Mash Potatoes

Oh potato—what big eyes you have! Oh potato…what big teeth you have! Spuds never looked so fierce, but these monster mash potatoes turn the plain old boring side into a spine-chilling face by piercing, mashing, and exposing the flesh and arranging green pepper triangles as teeth, black olives for eyes, chives for wild hair, and ketchup for a bit of blood spatter.

monster mash potatoes

Source: Curious Cuisiniere

8. Shrieking Goblin Flatbreads

If you’d like to serve up a truly tasty yet terrifying bread basket, these shrieking goblin flatbreads will certainly set your guests on cackle mode. Simply rolled with store-bought white or whole-wheat pizza dough, brushed with extra-virgin olive oil, sprinkled with salt, and baked until “ghoul-den” brown in the oven.

goblin

Source: Martha Stewart

9. Halloween Stuffed Peppers

These holiday-inspired stuffed peppers will tempt the ghouls and goblins to your table in their finest Halloween garb. Simply core, seed, and carve jack-o-lantern faces into orange, yellow, and red bell peppers and fill with a mixture of seasoned ground meat, chopped onion, garlic, rice, and tomato sauce.

Halloween-stuffed-peppers1

Source: Citronlimette.com

Advertisement

10. Dracula’s Dentures

And now for a Halloween dessert that you can really sink your teeth into—take a big bite out of Dracula’s dentures, in other words a row of mini marshmallows, red frosting, and slivered almonds sandwiched between 2 chocolate chip cookie halves.

dracula-dentures-set

Source: The Girl Who Ate Everything

11. Scary Cerebrum

Mmmmm brains! Treat your guests to a cerebral appetizer experience that they will never forget. In fact, they may have nightmares about this gory, molded shrimp cocktail for years to come. Just be sure to arrange your shrimp (tails intact) in layers with the round backs facing out. Line the outer edge with roasted red pepper strips (or blood vessels), chill to set, and dig in!

cerembrum shrimp

Source: BHG.com

12. Mini Batty Cheese Balls

Your guests will go batty over these pastrami, cream cheese, and horseradish infused appetizers. They really do have wings—or rather they will seem like they do when they disappear out of thin air with echoes of crunching and lip-smacking filling the air.

batty cheese balls

Source: Joann.com

13. Mini Mummy Bundt Cakes

These mini mummy Bundt cakes are far from scary when you consider they’re made with your choice of hot chocolate milk. You can even take the real evils out of Halloween (high fructose corn syrup and bovine growth hormones) when you choose to bake up a batch using nutrient rich TruMoo or chocolate almond milk.

Mini-Mummy-Bundt-Cakes

Source: Hip Foodie Mom

Anna

Anna adores cooking, drinking wine, and listening to records, but she does a lot of yoga to balance things out ;) This explains the black bean brownie disaster of 2007 (don't bring that up). She's noshed in countries like Greece, Turkey, France, Ireland, Costa Rica, and numerous other weird, yummy places that will get her waxing all poetic about her favorite recipes.

More Forkly
Like many other holidays, Halloween is a chance to go all out! This extends to decorating the house, creating extraordinary...
The most wonderful thing about children is the pure excitement for just about everything!
There’s nothing better than a new season that brings about all your childhood favorites and those mild food addictions that come...
When it comes to trick or treats—we all choose treats! However, if the thought of your little monsters eating handfuls of...
If you’re on a diet, Halloween is a scary holiday. Not only is it jam packed with sugary treats all day today, many of those...
Halloween is ripe for tricking. But let’s face it, what everyone really looks forward too are the treats.
Halloween, a time to delight in all things gross, creepy, scary and spooky - and then lace that with a gallon of sugar.
Halloween is a great time to go all out with decorations, costumes, and of course food!
Halloween is a great time for children. They get to dress up as superheros, fairy princess, or what ever they like.
It's a spooky time of year but with some sweet treats. Halloween parties are a great way for parents and adults to get in the...
When Halloween comes, people are divided into two groups- those that love candy, and those that want to spoil it for the rest of...
The leaves on the trees are turning colored and the wind now has a brisk edge. This can only mean one thing- Halloween is coming!
Advertisement
Food
Halloween Appetizers and Party Food Ideas: 10 Great Recipes!